- All Saints Catholic School of Endicott | Grades PreK - 6
- Bishop Grimes Jr./Sr. High School of East Syracuse | Grades 7 - 12
- Bishop Ludden Jr./Sr. High School of Syracuse | Grades 7 - 12
- Blessed Sacrament School of Syracuse | Grades PreK - 6
- Cathedral Academy at Pompei of Syracuse | Grades PreK - 6
- Holy Cross School of DeWitt | Grades PreK - 6
- Holy Family School of Syracuse | Grades PreK - 6
- Holy Family School-Norwich of Norwich | Grades PreK - 6
- Immaculate Conception School of Fayetteville | Grades PreK - 6
- Most Holy Rosary School of Syracuse | Grades PreK - 6
- Notre Dame Elementary of Utica | Grades PreK - 6
- Notre Dame Jr./Sr. High School of Utica | Grades 7 - 12
- Rome Catholic School of Rome | Grades PreK - 6
- Seton Catholic Central of Binghamton | Grades 7 - 12
- St. James School of Johnson City | Grades PreK - 6
- St. John the Evangelist School of Binghamton | Grades PreK - 6
- St. Mary's Academy of Baldwinsville | Grades PreK - 6
- St. Mary's School of Cortland | Grades PreK - 6
- St. Patrick's School of Oneida | Grades PreK - 6
- St. Rose of Lima School of North Syracuse | Grades PreK - 6
- Trinity Catholic School of Oswego | Grades PreK - 6